TwT

Teaching with Technology

This is a public blog  publicRSS

blog entry

    CHANGING HIGHER EDUCATION
    blog entry posted November 14, 2012 by Richard E Lillie, last edited November 14, 2012, tagged research 
    298 Views, 1 Comment
    title:
    CHANGING HIGHER EDUCATION
    intro text:

    Today, I learned about an outstanding blog published by Lloyd Armstrong titled Changing Higher Education.  He writes about a rapidly changing world driven by powerful forces such economics.politics, demographics, religion and technology.  Armstrong suggests that American universities have been affected only marginally by these forces so far; but, imagines it difficult to believe universities will not be changed in significant, perhaps radical, ways over the next few decades.  Armstrong focuses on forces impacting higher education.  I believe you will find this website to be a tremendous resource that challenges your thinking about what is happening in higher education.

    Rick Lillie (CSU San Bernardino)

     

     

    Comment

     

    • Robert E Jensen

      Teaching Case
      From The Wall Street Journal Weekly Accounting Review on May 16, 2014

      Studying Philosophy is Good for Business
      by: Marcelo Bucheli and R. Daniel Wadhwani
      May 12, 2014
      Click here to view the full article on WSJ.com
       

      TOPICS: Accounting Education

      SUMMARY: The article is written by two professors, one at the University of Illinoi, Urbana-Champaign and one at the University of the Pacific. The related article is the original report on changes in MBA programs to which these two professors have responded in this letter to the WSJ editors. The professors focus on market-related benefits of broad thinking capabilities. The related article describes employers' concerns about current teaching methods and focus in business programs.

      CLASSROOM APPLICATION: While the articles focus on MBA programs, questions ask students to consider whether these issues apply in accounting programs. The article may be used in any accounting class.

      QUESTIONS: 
      1. (Advanced) What do you understand is the meaning of critical thinking?

      2. (Introductory) What concerns are raised in the main and related articles about development of students' critical thinking skills in business programs?

      3. (Advanced) While the two articles are focused on MBA programs, do you feel that your accounting curriculum helps to develop your critical thinking skills? Support your answer.

      4. (Introductory) Refer to the related article. What do employers cite as a problem with the thinking skills of business school graduates?

      5. (Advanced) Could this issue being raised by employers apply to accounting graduates as well as MBAs? Explain.
       

      Reviewed By: Judy Beckman, University of Rhode Island
       

      RELATED ARTICLES: 
      Why Some M.B.A.s Are Reading Plato, Kant
      by Melissa Korn
      May 01, 2014
      Page: B6

      "Studying Philosophy is Good for Business," Marcelo Bucheli and R. Daniel Wadhwani, The Wall Street Journal, May 12, 2014 ---
      http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB20001424052702303948104579533610289092866

      Most business-school students are gunning for jobs in banking, consulting or technology. So what are they doing reading Plato?

      The philosophy department is invading the M.B.A. program—at least at a handful of schools where the legacy of the global financial crisis has sparked efforts to train business students to think beyond the bottom line. Courses like "Why Capitalism?" and "Thinking about Thinking," and readings by Marx and Kant, give students a break from Excel spreadsheets and push them to ponder business in a broader context, schools say.

      The courses also address a common complaint of employers, who say recent graduates are trained to solve single problems but often miss the big picture.

      "Nobel Thinking," a new elective at London Business School, explores the origins and influence of economic theories on topics like market efficiency and decision-making by some Nobel Prize winners. The 10-week course—taught by faculty from the school's economics, finance and organizational behavior departments—might not make students the next James Watson or Francis Crick, but it aims to give them a sense of how revolutionary ideas arise.

      "It's important to know why we're doing what we're doing," says Ingrid Marchal-Gérez, a second-year M.B.A. who enrolled in Nobel Thinking to balance her finance and marketing classes. "You can start to understand what idea can have an impact, and how to communicate an idea."

      Students write narrative essays to explain how ideas—such as adverse selection, or what happens when buyers and sellers have access to different information—gain currency. Joao Montez, the economics professor leading Nobel Thinking, says he wants students to reflect, if only for a short while, on world-changing thought.

      Career advancement and salary outrank ideas about world peace and humanity's future for many M.B.A.s, but Dr. Montez says LBS students have requested more opportunities to step back and consider big-picture ideas.

      "You can leave the classroom with these ideas in the back of your mind, and then maybe one day it will be useful," he says.

      That's true to a point: Ms. Marchal-Gérez, 38 years old, says she is somewhat concerned she'll "have a good time, but then what?"

      Abstract ideas remain a hard sell for many M.B.A.s.

      Patricia Márquez, an associate professor of management at the University of San Diego's School of Business Administration and an anthropologist by training, has struggled for nearly 20 years to teach M.B.A.s to dream up business solutions for poverty, her area of scholarly focus. Students, she found, needed a great deal of coaching to apply theories from anthropology and ethnography to the business world.

      She eventually replaced theory-based readings with traditional case studies, though she still tries to conduct discussions on abstract topics, such as how cultural stereotypes stymie innovation.

      "I spent six years thinking about the definition of culture. At a business school, culture can be measured through a survey," she says. "It's so solution-oriented. We don't ask, and we don't let them have space to ask better questions."

      To give students room for questions, Bentley University in Waltham, Mass., introduced "Thinking about Thinking" as a unit in its one-year M.B.A. program last year. Students spend two weeks studying art, reading fiction and even meditating.

      "There's too much emphasis in leadership work on understanding followers," says Duncan Spelman, management department chair and co-instructor. "We're really trying to emphasize understanding the self" to make students effective leaders.

      Mariia Potapkina, a 29-year-old Russia native who plans to work in consulting or strategy after graduation, says the class was "a nonstop, 14-day discovery of yourself." For example, she learned that she became more organized in the face of ambiguity.

      But ambiguity can be unsettling for some. Esteban Hunt, an M.B.A. student who hails from Buenos Aires, recalled a class when an artist presented a piece of artwork and asked students to describe what they saw.

      The variety of interpretations, and the realization that there was no single right answer, left him frustrated, Mr. Hunt says, and produced palpable anxiety among his classmates.

      That's the point, says Dr. Spelman, adding that uncertainty is a reality in life and business.

      Expect more abstract ideas in business schools soon.

      To meet student demand, Copenhagen Business School is expanding its 15-year-old master of science in business administration and philosophy program this year, shifting to English-language instruction from Danish and taking in more international students.

      "The tension between the two words business [and] philosophy appeals to quite a lot of young students," says Kurt Jacobsen, program director and a professor of business history. He says students want to better understand market and business dynamics after the extreme economic upheaval of recent years.

      Continued in article


      Critical Thinking:  Why's It So Hard to Teach
      Go to http://www.trinity.edu/rjensen/theory02.htm#CriticalThinking